Few places are as synonymous with Key West as Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe. Bright, playful, and proudly local, this iconic spot has built its reputation around one thing done exceptionally well: authentic Key lime pie. From classic slices to frozen treats on a stick, Kermit’s delivers a fun, flavorful experience that feels like a rite of passage for anyone visiting the island.
Review of Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop – Details
- Best For: Dessert lovers, first time Key West visitors, souvenirs, and casual sweet stops
- Location: Old Town, Key West, Florida, USA
- Type: Dessert Shop and Specialty Store
- Price Range: USD 6 to 12 per item
- Website: keylimeshop.com
- Instagram: @kermitskeylime
Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop Key West Review – Highlights
- Classic Key Lime Pie: Tart, creamy, and well balanced, with a crisp graham cracker crust. The flavor hits that perfect sweet-sour note that defines real Key lime pie.
- Frozen Pie on a Stick: The standout experience. Dipped in chocolate and served frozen, it is refreshing, indulgent, and ideal for Key West heat.
- Wide Variety of Lime Treats: From cookies and candies to sauces, jams, and snacks, everything leans into the Key lime theme without feeling gimmicky.
- Bright, Fun Atmosphere: The shop is colorful, lively, and unmistakably Key West. It feels joyful rather than touristy in a forced way.
- Easy Gifts and Souvenirs: Vacuum sealed pies and packaged treats make it simple to bring a taste of the island home.
- Consistent Quality: Despite the volume of visitors, the desserts remain reliable and well executed.
Review of Kermits Key Lime Pie Shop Florida – Things to Note
- Very Popular: Lines are common, especially midday.
- Sweet Focused Menu: This is about desserts only.
- Busy Interior: Small space that fills quickly.
- Strong Citrus Flavor: Those sensitive to tart desserts should pace themselves.
- Multiple Locations: Quality is consistent, but atmosphere varies slightly by shop.
Review of Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop – Tips
- Try Both: Get a classic slice and a frozen pie on a stick if you can.
- Visit Mid Morning or Evening: Shorter lines and less heat.
- Eat It Fresh: The pie shines most right after purchase.
- Ask About Shipping: Great option for gifts or holidays.
- Pair With a Walk: Enjoy it slowly while exploring Old Town.
Review of Kermit’s Key Lime Pie and Desserts – Photos and Menu
Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop delivers exactly what it promises: joyful, authentic Key West desserts with personality and flavor. It may be busy, colorful, and a bit chaotic at times, but that is part of its charm. The pies are genuinely good, the frozen treats are memorable, and the experience feels rooted in local tradition.
If you eat one dessert in Key West, make it this one.
Craving more gems? Check out our reviews of Le Peloton Cafe and Lomi.
For more ideas of things to do in Florida and reviews check it out here.